Thursday, March 17, 2011

GUNS N' ROSES "Hollywood Rose: The Roots of Guns N' Roses"

(c) 2004 Deadline Records
  1. Killing Time (original)
  2. Anything Goes (original)
  3. Rocker (original)
  4. Shadow Of Your Love (original)
  5. Reckless Life (original)
  6. Killing Time (Gilby Clarke Remix)
  7. Anything Goes (Gilby Clarke Remix)
  8. Rocker (Gilby Clarke Remix)
  9. Shadow Of Your Love (Gilby Clarke Remix) **
  10. Reckless Life (Gilby Clarke Remix) **
  11. Killing Time (Fred Coury Remix)
  12. Anything Goes (Fred Coury Remix)
  13. Rocker (Fred Coury Remix)
  14. Shadow Of Your Love (Fred Coury Remix)
  15. Reckless Life (Fred Coury Remix)
Axl Rose--Vocals
Chris Weber--Guitars, Bass
Izzy Stradlin--Guitars, Bass
Johnny Kreis--Drums
Tracii Guns--Guitar overdubs on tracks marked **

There was a time when ANYTHING that was associated with Guns N' Roses was going to sell, for one reason or another.  Deadline Records was fully aware that Axl was likely still years away from his next GnR album and took advantage of the band's fans' hunger for new material when they put out this collection of demo tracks from the pre-GnR band Hollywood Rose.  Consisting of future Gunners Axl and Izzy, along with a couple of now-no-names, this incarnation of the future mega-band recorded the original five tracks on this disc in 1984.  Naturally, Axl got angry (when isn't he angry) and filed a lawsuit to try to keep this collection from being released, but he must have failed because it is out there for all to grab.

I have to be honest...I think I know why Axl filed suit to keep these tracks from being released.  Simply put, they are not good.  "Anything Goes" is NOT the same track you hear on the legendary Appetite For Destruction  with the exception of the chorus.  "Rocker" is a revved-up, yet lyrically lame, attempt to explain the lifestyle being lived by Rose and his motley gang of musicians, and "Killing Time"...well, I'm not real sure what that is even about!  The most interesting of the songs here are the last two, "Shadow Of Your Love" and "Reckless Life" as both were co-written by not only Axl and Izzy, but also Duff McKagen and Slash, who gets co-write credits under his actual last name of Hudson.  While neither is a particularly strong song, they would show a bit more of where the band would be headed in the future.

Tracks 6-10 are the same as the first five except these were all remixed by one-time Gunner, Gilby Clarke.  Additionally, another future-ex-Gunner, Tracii Guns, ads guitar overdubs to "Shadow..." and "Reckless Life".  The final five tracks, 11-15 are again the same five songs, this time remixed by Cinderella drummer, Fred Coury.

In all honesty, I only purchased this album because I was in a record store planning to buy a CD but it had not come in.  With some cash burning a hole in my pocket, I decided to take a chance on this.  I wish I hadn't.  Other than for nostalgia and collection purposes, I really don't see a reason to own this.  The two tracks with Tracii Guns on them are decent, but, come one really needs to hear three slightly different versions of the same, demo-quality songs.  We all know how great this band was going to be in very short order, but at this time, this is NOT the Guns N Roses we came to love.

Rating:  Turn it down to 3...maybe bumping up Tracii's tracks to five or so....

1 comment:

  1. HOW can you call yourself a gutter or sleaze site and NOT like these 5 demos. In my mind, they are better than anything guns n roses would do from appetite on. Maybe axl was embarrased because this was his TRUE visiona nd direction from the start. A blatant glam band. And of course he and others learned to leave that in the past and go for a "dirtier" style. But the two songs you at least thought were good were also the big songs from their "Live Like A Suicide" album that was them pretending it was live. To me this and Live Like A Suicide is GNR at their best. Most raw, least polished and radio-friendly and sleaziest! So go back and listen to these gems again and try to tell me that an overrated album like AFD which was polished up 5000 times more than this one is truly better GNR. But then again I also like the first Ratt EP better than Cellar and everything else that band did as well. You catch my drift...>